A Hinge screenshot went viral on X this week, and it's the kind of thing that makes guys second-guess every date idea they've ever had. A guy suggests a first date at a wine bar on a Tuesday at 7 PM. Her reply: "Lol bodega wine bar? ๐ Are you like broke?" Here's the post:
Credit to @WestsideLAGuy for sharing it. He pushed back ("It's a perfectly fine spot, not sure what you were expecting on a FIRST date"), and she doubled down, saying she wanted to see more effort and that another guy bought her a $4K bag after a second date.
The replies split the way you'd expect. Some said a wine bar on a Tuesday really is lazy. Most guys reading it just quietly wondered: wait, is drinks a bad first date?
Honesty note: all I know about this exchange is what's in the screenshots. I can't verify the $4K bag, I don't know her side of the story, and I don't know what she was actually thinking. I'm not going to guess at her motives. Whether drinks are "low effort" is also an opinion, not a fact. I don't have survey data on it, and I'm not going to pretend I do. What follows is my take as someone who looks at a lot of dating profiles and chats.
Two different questions are hiding in this screenshot
Before we get to date ideas, it helps to pull apart two things that got mashed together in the replies.
Question one: what do you do when someone wants expensive "effort" before you've even met? If a match wants a luxury date or gifts up front and compares you to a guy who spent thousands, that's her filter. She's allowed to have it. You're also allowed to not be the guy who passes it. That's not a date idea problem, and no restaurant choice fixes it.
Question two: is drinks actually a weak first date from Hinge? This is the useful one, because plenty of women who'd never ask for a bag still have opinions about where a first date happens. Most of this post is about question two. I'll come back to question one at the end.
Is drinks a good first date?
My honest answer: drinks are a fine first date, and often a smart one, as long as you picked the spot on purpose. Here's why it's the default for so many people meeting from an app:
- It's short by design. One drink can be 45 minutes. If it's going well, you order another. If it isn't, nobody's stuck through three courses.
- It's easy to say yes to. A drink is a smaller ask than dinner. You're meeting a stranger from your phone, so a smaller ask is a feature.
- It's built for talking. The point of a first date is to find out if you actually like each other in person. A bar where you can hear each other does that better than a movie or a loud event.
- It doesn't cost a fortune. You don't know this person yet. Spending big before you've talked face to face just makes the stakes weird.
Where drinks go wrong isn't the drinks. It's a place so loud you're shouting, or "wanna grab a drink sometime?" with no plan at all. Effort isn't about the bill. It's about whether it looks like you thought about it.
Notice the guy in the screenshot actually did the hard part right. He named a specific place, a day, and a time. That's better than what most guys send. Whether that wine bar fit her, I have no idea.
Drinks vs coffee vs dinner for a first date from Hinge
There's no single right answer, so here's how I'd think about the common options.
Drinks
Good default for evenings. Pick a place with seats, where you can hear each other, and that feels a little nicer than your usual spot. Cocktail bars, wine bars, a hotel lobby bar, somewhere with a patio. Skip it if either of you doesn't drink, or if her profile says she's sober or "not big on bars." That's a sign to suggest something else, not to push.
Coffee or a walk
Best when either of you wants an easy exit. It's low pressure and works on a weekend afternoon. Sitting across a table can feel like a job interview, so a coffee you carry on a walk is usually better. If she's mentioned being nervous about meeting people from apps, this is a kind option.
Dinner
Higher cost and higher commitment. You're locked in for an hour and a half or more with someone you've never met. Some people like that it feels like a "real date," and that's fair. But if the chat has been short, I'd save dinner for date two.
First date ideas on Hinge: what to actually say in the chat
Where you go matters less than how you ask. Here's what works:
- Be specific. Place, day, time. "Want to grab a drink at [place] Thursday around 7?" beats "we should hang out sometime" every single time.
- Give a reason for the spot. One line does it. "They have a patio and the best old fashioned I've had." "You said you love natural wine, this place has a list that's kind of ridiculous." A reason turns "a bar" into a plan.
- Use her profile. If her prompts mention tacos, hiking, live jazz, or a favorite neighborhood, build the date around that. It shows you actually read what she wrote, which is the effort that counts.
- Have a backup ready. If she says she's not a big drinker or prefers something else, don't get defensive. "Totally, coffee and a walk around [area] Saturday afternoon?" Easy.
- Ask at the right time. Once you've had a few good back-and-forths, ask. Don't let it drag on for weeks. If you're stuck before that, see how to keep a conversation going on Hinge.
Here's a simple template:
"This has been fun, I'd like to keep it going in person. There's a wine bar in [neighborhood] with a great patio. Are you free Thursday around 7? If drinks aren't your thing, I'm happy to do coffee instead."
That's specific, it has a reason, and it gives her an easy alternative. Nobody reasonable reads that as low effort.
If she says "that's low effort"
Sometimes you'll suggest something and get a lukewarm reply. That's not always a red flag. Maybe she's been to that bar a hundred times. The easy move is to ask: "Fair, what's a spot you've been wanting to try?" That's not caving. It's just being flexible, and you might end up somewhere better.
What you shouldn't do is start upgrading the date to prove something. If you go from "wine bar" to "fancy steakhouse" because someone implied you're broke, you're now negotiating, not dating.
Red flags to walk away from
Back to question one. Some reactions aren't about the date spot at all. These are the ones I'd treat as a polite exit:
- Gift or money talk before you've met. Asking what you'll buy her, or bringing up what other guys bought her, before a single date.
- "Prove you're not broke." Any version of testing your bank account instead of getting to know you.
- Comparing you to other guys' spending. If the conversation turns into a ranking of who spent more, you already know how the date would go.
- Mocking the idea instead of suggesting one. Not liking a spot is fine. Laughing at you for it and offering nothing else isn't.
When you see these, don't argue, don't screenshot it for a debate, and don't send a long message explaining yourself. "No worries, I don't think we're a fit. Good luck out there." Then unmatch and move on.
To be fair, the screenshot went viral because it's unusual. Don't let one extreme exchange make you overthink every date you suggest.
Getting matches but they never turn into dates? Sometimes the problem starts with the profile, not the ask. The $19 Profile Grade tells you your biggest issues within 24 hours. Every profile is reviewed by me, by hand.
First date on Hinge FAQ
Is drinks a good first date?
Usually, yes. Drinks are short, easy to say yes to, and good for talking, which is the point of a first date. Pick a spot where you can hear each other, give a reason for choosing it, and offer coffee instead if she doesn't drink.
Is drinks a low-effort first date?
Not by itself. Whether it reads as low effort is opinion, and it depends on how you ask. A specific place, day, and time with a reason for the spot shows effort. A vague "wanna grab a drink sometime" doesn't.
What should I suggest for a first date on Hinge?
Something short and easy to say yes to: drinks, coffee and a walk, or an activity tied to her prompts. Name the place, day, and time, and have a backup idea ready in case she prefers something else.
The short version
A viral Hinge screenshot shows a wine-bar first date getting called "broke." Her reasons and the $4K bag story are unverified, and whether drinks are "low effort" is an opinion. In my view, drinks are a good first date if you pick the spot on purpose, give a reason, and name a day and time. Coffee or a walk works for an easy exit, and dinner can wait for date two. If someone wants proof of your spending before you've met, wish her well and move on. And if you're not getting to the date stage at all, start with the $19 Profile Grade.